Investors have been using futures and derivatives contracts in metals, agricultural products, currencies and other risk-related investments to hedge against losses for decades.
Now, a group is trying to add diamond contracts to the list of exchange-traded instruments.
The Rapaport Group, a diamond price and information provider, will hold the first of planned monthly online diamond auctions Monday through Thursday. Transaction prices will be used to create an index in hopes of developing a diamond futures market.
"We're creating a new level of transparency for diamond prices," said Martin Rapaport, chairman of the Rapaport Group. "It's going to open up a cornucopia of opportunities for the diamond market."
Bidding will be for 210 lots, each lot a single stone, and will be open to the diamond trade and financial institutions. Consumers can access the auction via a registered market participant. Auction terms will be spot cash, free on board, with a 3 percent commission charged to sellers, who will be paid within five business days of the auction's close.
All the talk about diamond derivatives isn't new.
In 1972, 194 diamond contracts were traded on the West Coast Commodities Exchange over a two week period before prices collapsed and the exchange ended diamond futures trading, according to the Diamond Registry, quoting author Edward Jay Epstein.
"It's been tried before," said David Prager, director of communications for DeBeers, the world's largest diamond producer. "Let's see what happens, but there's not an opinion from DeBeers."
Diamonds, similar to other commodities, are tied to wider economic indicators like consumer demand and inflation, Rapaport said.
Critics say diamond futures would be hard to price because each diamond is unique, unlike, for example, gold bullion in standardized quantities and purity.
The auction will track prices for one specific type of diamond and later may branch out to other types, Rapaport responded.
Another critic, whose company is competing against Rapaport to create pricing for future exchange-traded contracts, also has qualms about the auction.
"I really don't buy into the concept of using a tender to set the market prices," said Charles Wyndham, founder of PolishedPrices.com, a diamond price and information platform.
"To start coming out and saying this is going to be transparent and a base for a derivatives market, I just don't see it," Wyndham said. "Are his mates bidding for the stones to create a market?"
Rapaport said tender offers are good ways to create an index for a futures market because they involve multiple buyers and sellers who are under no compulsion. The auctions will provide spot cash transaction prices, not just asking prices, he said.
"Auctions are a clear, crispy crunchy vehicle to observe," he said. "It's free, open, competitive, efficient markets. We know who the buyers and sellers are. There are real buyers and real sellers."
He added that when Rapaport moves to the futures market stage, the group will go through regulators.
"At this stage I think this is a perfectly legitimate auction," Rapaport said. "We are not trading any stones, we are not buying or selling anything."
Rapaport said there are "absolutely" no conflicts of interest with the diamond auction. The Rapaport Group serves as a broker and clearing house but "we don't own any of the product."
The group will only progress to the futures market stage if the trading can be inclusive, transparent and receive regulatory approval, Rapaport said. If all that gets done, diamond futures contracts could begin trading in two years on an exchange.
Wyndham said PolishedPrices is coming along with its own plans for a diamond derivatives market.
No comments:
Post a Comment